Review: The Red Sacrament
/5 stars. I'm tempted to say this deserves 5 stars because it's an exquisite masterpiece; a debut as twinkly as it is bloody. But really I'm giving it that rating for the reading experience itself - for the escape and the immersion and the vivid ... depth to which I could swim in it. I've read a lot of reviews trying to sort out my thoughts with no luck, but I think I have a lot to say. Let's get into it.
The Red Sacrament beautifully presents for us the tale of Arnault, vampire in Paris. He and his brood (literal) have successfully run a theater for decades, perfecting their craft and preying on their nightly audience. And then they are visited by a witch, followed by sibling vampires, who shake Arnault out of his stasis. The second half of the story is set against the backdrop of war, Paris under siege, then violent revolution - to which Arnault bears witness, and is changed forever.
Much has been written about the political sub- and above-texts here. Old vs new; rich vs poor; upper vs lower class; urban vs rural; monster vs human; poverty vs excess; and much more as the story explores capitalism, modernity, exploitation, societal transformation, and resistance to it. The “Marx meets Anne Rice” tagline is accurate. And I think I understand, somewhat, where Sara Hinkley was going, though I'm not smart enough to analyze it effectively. I just really enjoy the fact that most horror is political, and I would like to read more books - especially historical horror - that lean into this.
I can say that books like this will make you a better thinker, and maybe even a better writer. There's so, so much to chew on - or maybe I should say, drink in. The Red Sacrament will educate you, and throw new color on old legends. It will give you a new appreciation for language and art and imagery and history. It's well-researched, and it will inspire further research. It makes complex political and social placefinding so, so entertaining and fascinating.
I am deeply interested in the narrative choices - especially the ending - and the stylistic ones. Purple prose isn't always my thing - and yeah, I rolled my eyes a couple of times. I snorted at it, I got tired of it. Oh, the drama! The melodrama! So many complaints about the slow plot and the flat characters and the repetition - I see what people mean, but those things didn't bother me so much.
I guess this is/was my cup of tea, aesthetically and thematically. Right book, right time. I found it to be dreamy and unpredictable and certain moments took my breath away. I was captivated, especially toward the end. I've been tinkering with this review for like five days because frankly, I don't really want to let this book go. I can't wait to see what the author writes next.
On my Christmas wish list for Santa this year: an illustrated version; a spin-off, or a sequel, or even a prequel; and an adaptation, on crunchy film with natural lighting and practical effects.
This "review" is very much all about me and my reaction to The Red Sacrament, and not a whole lot about The Red Sacrament itself. I suggest reading this excellent review for better commentary. And for more: Interview with the Vampire (the book by Anne Rice is the obvious mothertext here, but the movie is also a must-watch - TRS is no rip-off, it's a complement and a compliment); Penny Dreadful (tv show); The Queen of the Night (book by Alexander Chee - there is even a hot air balloon!); you know what would also be an interesting supplemental watch? Versailles (tv show), which gives a sparkly, wiggy, very inaccurate look at French royalty and excess.
The Red Sacrament on: Amazon | Bookshop.org | Goodreads | StoryGraph