Review: A Song of Shadows (Charlie Parker #13)

I didn't enjoy this as much as The Wolf in Winter, but it's easy to call it a fantastic entry in Charlie Parker's story - by now, #13 in the series, John Connolly has sharpened his arsenal of storytelling weapons and deploys them very, very effectively. I've mentioned this before, but I like how the series deals with a variety of subjects - each mystery dives deep into something - and it inspires me to daydream about other possible settings for Charlie - the circus? Capitol Hill? Charlie Parker in Hollywood? Charlie Parker goes to Paris?

In this one: Nazis. Parker moves to a small seaside town in Maine to recover from serious injuries sustained in the last book, and - naturally - gets pulled into an investigation when a body washes up on shore. Navigating small town politics, his unfortunate and extensive personal traumas, and a growing awareness of what else is out there, Charlie pulls on threads that extend all the way back to one of the worst and most painful periods in human history. 

You can tell this book features a subject that interests Connolly greatly and his research is incredibly apparent. I was impressed with the ... maybe not nuanced, exactly, but the careful portrayal of Holocaust perpetrators in old age. Their stories are as fascinating as they are horrifying - Connolly does not shy away from the vivid and grotesque details of their crimes past and present, nor does he neglect to examine closely (and not always favorably) the way the world reacted - and continues to react. 

I liked the pacing and the balance in this one, too. I truly did not guess any of the twists and was very engaged start to finish. I was honestly a little confused here and there, trying to keep track of the characters and the details, but that could be thanks to pregnancy-fueled focus issues and fatigue. I'm very intrigued by where things are going next - I love that Charlie ends this one with a strong purpose.

Isn't it interesting to reflect back on Every Dead Thing? That book was super, super long and winding and sentence heavy... Charlie hadn't grown into his character's skin yet and there was such a 90s flavor to it. We've come such a long way! I'm thrilled there's more and I am thrilled to see where the story continues - even though I have a feeling it's going to be very, very dark. Bring it on.

A Song of Shadows on: Amazon | Bookshop.org | Goodreads | StoryGraph

Review: A Gathering of Ghosts

4 stars. Maitland is an incredible author - y'all are begging and screaming for anything that smells even REMOTELY like Between Two Fires and she's RIGHT HERE! This is the deeply researched, immersive, medieval horror you're looking for! And she has a ton of books to choose from - this was a little more up my alley than Company of Liars, but both = very memorable, enjoyable reading experiences. 

England, mid-1300s. The Priory of St Mary is visited by a series of unexpected visitors: a Knight of St John, dispatched to review the Priory's financial activities and accounts related to the church; a young girl, alone and impoverished who lands in a nearby camp of tinners but feels called to something more; and a child, blind, whose arrival coincides with a violent death. In a rough landscape made rougher by the tinners, the Priory's inhabitants are caught between honoring the church and protecting their own survival. 

I particularly loved the lack of traditional heroes/villains in this story. You really are plopped down in the middle of a situation where characters orbit each other and interact in interesting - but not necessarily archetypal - ways. I also really loved the interplay of old and new religions - it's a Big and Common Theme, and in this case, one religion is literally stacked on top of another. The author dramatically paints the conflict around traditional beliefs evolving and blurring into something new, and the intersection of all that with economics and politics and power, and gender, of course...

Okay, so one quibble: multiple times I found myself wanting this book to get to the point. It's not that it dragged, exactly, but there was a lot of ... circling the drain, so to speak, and we spent a lot of time inner monologuing in repetitive ways. Character motivations were well-established 75% of the way through, we didn't need to keep wallowing in their wallowing. I would also mention that the author asks a lot of you - there's a handy glossary, and a historical guide, but there are terms and concepts and references here that will be unfamiliar to anyone but a medieval expert. I didn't mind - for me it didn't detract from the story. In fact, that helped make it compelling. 

This is a medieval fairy tale without a single drop of romanticism: it's gritty, muddy, dank, gross, dark, wet, dreary, mossy, smoky, smelly, dirty, cruel, bloody, and terrifying. Wrong and right are twisted and twisted again into a fascinating knot. There are multiple types of horror: atmospheric, religious, supernatural, demonic, animal horror, body horror, human horror... I highly, highly recommend. 

A Gathering of Ghosts on: Amazon | Bookshop.org | Goodreads | StoryGraph

Review: The Diamond in the Window

5 stars. This book captivated me when I was younger - both my sister and I inherited it as a particular favorite of our mother’s. A family mystery, dream clues, an attic bedroom tucked away? We re-read it many times. We were also read other books in Jane Langton's repertoire (I can practically hear my dad's voice...) and enjoyed them all immensely. So I opened this with intense curiosity, hoping it would hold up. And it was... a fascinating experience.

Eleanor and Edward live in a very special house in Concord with their Aunt Lily and Uncle Freddy. They live a peaceful if somewhat sad family life, as several relatives are missing - having disappeared under mysterious circumstances years ago. When two very unpleasant townspeople threaten to repossess the house due to taxes owed, the children embark on a vivid, fantastic, dangerous treasure hunt to find their family and save their house.

From a writing perspective, this book is pretty much perfect. The descriptions are imaginative and colorful and captivating, the pacing is great for kids, and the way E&E's real-life experiences informed the dream games was honestly really fun. There are some important lessons embedded maybe not so subtly around selflessness, sacrifice, identity, knowledge, and choices - I stand by them. 

But I don't love that Eleanor's mirror path led her to motherhood, and Edward's reflected him as President. There were some odd religious overtones (or maybe undertones?)… just some intense/weird religious imagery that confused me... but honestly didn't phase me for a second as a kid. That stuff went right over my head - I never once connected it to religion in any way. So much for being “exposed” to dangerous concepts... I guess I was too dumb to be "corrupted."

So, yes, halfway through I was feeling 4 stars. But the ending wraps things up so beautifully - so, so beautifully - I can’t help but give it 5. It's a wonderful, transporting, adventure story. There are some dark and spooky moments which only add to the thrill. And these characters - you cannot help but love them, deeply. Uncle Freddy forever.

The Diamond in the Window on: Amazon | Bookshop.org | Goodreads | StoryGraph

Review: The Egypt Game

5 stars. Could not have enjoyed this more - it had me staying up late, "one more chapter" and all that! I wonder if this book kickstarted my Egypt phase, back in the day? Regardless, I highly, highly recommend this for readers of all ages - it's a timeless classic, an important story, and a ridiculously fun, good time. I cried at the end (pregnant). 

When young April Hall moves to town, she quickly befriends Melanie Ross, discovering a mutual love for all things Ancient Egypt. Together with Melanie's younger brother Marshall they invent The Egypt Game, adopting an old storage shed behind a junk shop for their rituals and ceremonies. But as the Game grows, strange things happen, and the players start to wonder if they've conjured the magic of Ancient Egypt after all...

I actually cannot believe how well-written and clever this is. The author really channels - successfully - the quirks and voices of the kids, infusing some really important and powerful lessons into the narrative. The representation - for a book published in 1967 - is incredible, and I nearly dropped the book when I realized there's a MURDER SUBPLOT?! What do you mean? Could this book be any further up my alley?

There's plenty for adults. It's a throwback to the joy of immersive, imaginative play, and there are clever references to the tensions of its time: the Civil Rights movement, for example. I don't think it's an accident that the murderer turned out to be a white ginger from a well-respected family. It's funny, and insightful without knocking you over the head, and don't even get me started on Mr. Ross calling April "the cruelest month...." 

I loved this book as a kid, and I love it now. There's so much to read, out there, but let this be a sign: revisit the good ones, occasionally. It's very rewarding.

The Egypt Game on: Amazon | Bookshop.org | Goodreads | StoryGraph

Review: The Wolf in Winter (Charlie Parker #12)

4 stars. This series tells some fascinating stories of different shapes and sizes. I normally prefer consistency, but I appreciate the variety here: some are more focused on Charlie, some on his associates; some are more focused on the crime or mystery at hand with Charlie as a secondary character; some are more horror, others more procedural; some are cut-and-dry as a bone while others include supernatural components. I guess I'm trying to communicate what to expect, but it's also an observation around why I think this series is so successful: it keeps things interesting.

The Wolf in Winter zooms in on a small town in Maine called Prosperous. The town has experienced good fortune over the years, despite economic downturn and global conflict, thanks to the inhabitants' commitment to an old god who demands a lot more than worship every Sunday. When a girl goes missing, Charlie Parker gets involved, poking his nose in the dark corners of a church with strange carvings and inviting a lot more trouble than usual. 

Connolly pays a lot of attention to Prosperous itself - its residents, its enforcers, its crimes. It's not exactly the most unique premise, but I found the power squabbles, tensions, and clashing personalities endlessly fascinating. We have an anti-hero, of sorts, bumping up against an egomaniac pseudo-pastor, decision makers who enjoy the bloodshed a little too much, and one of the best and most irritating villains in the series - their leader. There are echoes of The Lottery in the bureaucracy of it all. I really, really enjoyed this aspect of the story. And The Green Man is always, always, always of interest, to me.

That being said, I had to dock a star for a UDD (or a UWD as it were), and because - despite being pretty tight and shorter than other Parker books - it could've used maybe a bit more editing/less meandering. But that's par for the course here and I was immersed, as usual, in the unexpected familiar and safe space that is Parker's world. It's less of a whodunnit but the way these characters orbit each other had me chomping at the bit to find out what happens next. Also, I know I've thrown my support behind this series being adapted before, but SERIOUSLY, THIS IS THE ONE. 

The Wolf in Winter on: Amazon | Bookshop.org | Goodreads | StoryGraph

Review: The Reyes Incident

2 stars. Hmmm. Am I missing something? Entertaining enough, and easy to understand, but this novella - though a fairly well-told story - packs absolutely zero punches. Maybe I just wasn't in the mood (pregnant and grumpy), or maybe it focused on the wrong things (off-kilter romances), or maybe it just wasn't scary at all (though tense, at parts!). Or maybe it needed to be longer? 

A group of urbex YouTubers venture into an old military bunker in the middle of a forest and encounter a group of sirens. AKA evil mermaids. These creatures stalk them, hunt them, and eat them, picking them off one-by-one. The survivor, a young woman named Olivia Reyes, manages to escape and make her way to a police station, where she's interviewed by a Sergeant with personal problems - and a personal stake - of her own.

A couple of things, in addition to the stuff I mentioned above: the sirens/evil mermaids - although it sounds like they looked really cool - were not intimidating or scary at all. Their names were extremely silly. I think some of the more emotional parts (scenes of grief, angst, break-ups, declarations of love) would've been more effective had we known the characters for longer. Speaking of, the characters themselves acted so weird. And the timing/pacing was off. I guarantee the police would've held that girl until her statement was done. One night. Boom.

A great idea for a vignette, like a monster-of-the-week episode of X-Files or something (though Scully would've pegged the real killer immediately), but ultimately not a hit for me.

The Reyes Incident on: Amazon | Bookshop.org | Goodreads | StoryGraph

Review: The Weejee Man

4 stars. An absolute blast. I highly recommend this fun, spooky, atmospheric novella for fans of ghost stories. It's Irish as hell and full of twists and turns, and altogether inappropriate to read during an East Coast heat wave. But I gobbled up every word.

Rick Rooney, former prolific horror author, travels from London to his rural hometown in Ireland to embark on a digital detox and tackle his crippling writer's block. An evening in the local pub turns spooky when he's goaded into using a spirit board - and things only get spookier from there. A creepy encounter in the fog, the appearance of a strange, dark figure... Rick attempts to investigate a local legend in the hopes of finding answers, but the haunting escalates in dark, dangerous directions he never could've imagined.

An author protagonist suffering from writer's block? But Kelly! You may gasp, in terror. That's your pet peeve! Yes, it absolutely is, and I didn't care so much this time around, because it doesn't actually drive the story all that much. All is forgiven... this time.

Honestly, what the heck happened here though? Where can I find some theories and interpretations? I love that this went somewhere I truly didn't expect, and I love some well-placed ambiguity/unanswered questions, but I'm dying to talk about it. There's a lot packed into this little book, and I want to know more! All I can think of is some sort of... supernatural justice for messing with things you absolutely should not.

For fans of: Irish mythology, Irish folklore, Irish horror, horror tropes, detailed descriptions of Irish cabins and pubs, brandy, epistolary clues, graveyards, spooky lakes. 

The Weejee Man on: Amazon | Bookshop.org | Goodreads | StoryGraph

Review: Experimental Film

5 stars. Overjoyed to report that my thirst for reading is back after a short break due to first trimester illness and blues (this happened last time too). I missed my Kindle, I missed the escape, and I missed the bone deep satisfaction earned from an immersive story. But I just couldn't read. I wasn't sure if I'd have to give up on this book, honestly, because certain things get unfortunately associated with nausea when you're pregnant, but I was really determined with this one - I sensed something in it, and persevered - I'm so glad I did.

Because it ended up saving me during a particularly difficult week - chasing around a toddler on a beach trip - like, truly engulfing me after the meltdowns and the overstimulation and the stressful World Cup games took their toll. I was thrilled to read even a few pages here and there, stolen in between tantrums and during naps. I absolutely adored Lois' voice and I really rooted for her. She's an incredibly strong and real-feeling protagonist.

I'm getting ahead of myself. Experimental Film is about an out-of-work film critic/former film professor who stumbles upon the vivid work of one of Canada's original filmmakers, a woman who, after the disappearance of her son, also disappears under mysterious circumstances. Lois receives a grant to investigate, but her research leads her down a strange and apparently dangerous path for her family. 

I have seen other reviews criticize this book for a couple of things: for being derivative of certain works - American Gods is one, Night Film is another; for the infodump/detailed exposition about the Canadian film industry; for the slow first half. And I get it, I really do. But I happened to love both AG and NF, and recognized the info dumping as an intentional piece of Lois' characterization. I would argue that this book is in fact large part character study, which makes it even crazier and more interesting when Lois has to channel both her best and worst instincts during the final climax. 

It's not a book for everyone. But I absolutely loved the central mystery here, as well as the primary antagonist, and the way everything unfolded. I appreciated Simon's strength and support as a partner. I understood Lois' struggles as a parent of a child on the spectrum. I gobbled up the descriptions of the films, the threads of dark mythology and folk horror, and the spooky moments. The historical lore is truly disturbing here and I kind of wanted more. 

Idk. This one felt really, really special. I feel like I have so much more to say, but I want to say it to someone who's read it - there's a lot to discuss. And while we’re listing things we want, an illustrated and/or annotated version would be very welcome, thanks very much :)

Experimental Film on: Amazon | Bookshop.org | Goodreads | StoryGraph

Review: Falling Angel

4 stars. This was an absolutely fascinating, stylistic, colorful reading experience - a true mystery, a true New York noir, a true detective novel through and through. Super trope-y - which I loved - and very, very dark. In a fun way, mostly. I couldn't get enough, and I'm excited to check out the adaptation, and maybe the sequel (though I've seen mixed reviews on that one).

Private investigator Harry Angel is hired to track down an old famous singer by the name of Johnny Favorite, who disappeared after returning injured from the war. The more he learns, the more Angel gets caught up in black magic, the occult, and the true intentions of his dastardly, enigmatic client. The path to finding Johnny Favorite, apparently, is soaked in blood.

I did dock a star - the portrayal and treatment of women is supremely gross, and there's also a UAD (unnecessary animal death). I also couldn't help but find this book to be very pleased with itself. Not denying that it's a good twist - there was just something a little... smug about it.

But I really enjoyed so many of the successful elements: the crunchy, snappy, classic Noir dialogue; the vivid depiction of New York; the way each clue fell into place. I was really rooting for Angel, almost against my better judgement (my spidey senses started tingling about 80% of the way through). I've seen this described as a horror/noir hybrid, and... I want more, because the flavor was deeply compelling and satisfying to me.

Falling Angel on: Amazon | Bookshop.org | Goodreads | StoryGraph

Review: The Wrath of Angels (Charlie Parker #11

5 stars. Oh hell yeah, Connolly crushed this. We got a super dark thriller, we got the return of an epic villain, we got some grade A banter with Angel and Louis, we got a glimpse of Colonial horror (finally! the series is set in New England, after all!) and, best of all, we got some answers. Absolutely loved it.

Our poor dear detective Charlie Parker is hired by two acquaintances whose fathers have recently passed away - but not before sharing the details of a secret discovery made years before: the crashsite of a plane, deep in the woods, and with it, money - a lot of money, and a list of names. Parker immediately realizes the importance of this list, and enlists the help of his old friends to ensure he finds it before it falls into the wrong, evil hands.

John Connolly is building a truly impressive mythology here - one that is quite dark and scary. The pieces are falling into place and I'm so pleased to report that even 10+ books later my memory hasn't failed me in any major ways. I'm not quite sure how to explain this, but it feels like the author really, really tried with this one - with the plotting, the pacing, and the way the characters orbited each other. His efforts paid off.

I particularly enjoyed the inclusion of local folklore, here, and the way it intersected with the main plot. It lended a fresh, spooky edge to the setting as well as a very satisfying demise of a certain character. Sometimes Connolly's deep dives into character or place can be tedious; here it was fascinating and fun. 

Look - these books are a bit ridiculous, okay? A list of names - really? A sophisticated shadow organization with unlimited resources and they rely on hard copies? But I truly didn't mind. I loved that the list created this sort of dark treasure hunt vibe - a set-up for a terrific reveal.

I am excited to keep the series going. This should really be a TV series.

The Wrath of Angels on: Amazon | Bookshop.org | Goodreads | StoryGraph