Review: Demon (Six Stories #6)

4 stars. Absolutely devastated that this may be the end of one of my favorite series of all time. I picked up the first book when I really needed it - needed an easy, compelling distraction from the stress of living, and I immediately bought the rest, which... I don't think has happened since before I knew how to read. I would just hate to say goodbye to Scott King forever. My true crime- mystery- creepy horror-loving heart is broken.

In Demon, King decides to rake over the grave of a young boy named Sydney Parsons, who was murdered in 1995 by two other boys of his age. The crime took place in a very small town called Ussalthwaite, which appears cozy and picturesque even as its residents skirt around strange happenings and eerie history. Scott of course interviews those connected directly or indirectly with the tragedy, attempting to track down answers to the many questions swirling: primarily, motive. As with all of the Six Stories books, there's an undercurrent of the supernatural that absolutely delivers serious chills in each interview.

Other reviewers have noted that this ends with a touch more ambiguity than some of the others, which on one hand is frustrating, but only I think because the others land so clearly, with solid, grounding answers that give a sense of completion. Leaving elements of the story open-ended undeniably made it a scarier book, and therefore, naturally, I'm really, really into it. 

I also noticed that this one had a somewhat stronger, or maybe less subtle, agenda to it. Don't get me wrong, the last few years of politics and pandemics and promotion of ignorance have filled me with enough rage to fill even the coziest of lighthearted novels with attacks on society's current, perplexing, direction. And Matt Wesolowsi always - admirably - explores big themes in his mysteries. In this case, nature vs nurture vs neglect, punishment vs rehabilitation, criminal rights, prison reform, the justice system... But here his views are a little more loud. He took the flying brick approach. And I don't hate it (in fact I agree with it), but I did find it slightly distracting.

And I can't forget to mention that there was a UDD. And yes, my instinct told me to dock a star for it, but I didn't, because he included a suitably written trigger warning. That way I didn't have to spend the whole time stressed about the dog, I could just skip over detailed descriptions of her so I didn't get too attached. (Appropriate time to mention that this is probably the darkest, maybe most disturbing, of them all, which is saying something. You've been warned.)

I should also say - I had absolutely 0 theories for this one, leading up to the very last few pages. Typically in the middle of a Six Stories book I'd tell my husband my theory (who, despite having no context or understanding, took notes so he could validate me later), and I'd say I was right in 4/6 books. But this one? Left me totally guessing. I was like, fake death? Twins? Evil doppelgänger? Dissassociative identity disorder or multiple personalities? WTF Is going on here?!?! WTF was with the creepy singing?!?! I NEED MORE!!

I cannot say enough good stuff about this series. Each book offers its own unique, but familiar at the same time, flavor. I've mentioned this before, but what should have gotten stale after 3+ books only got better. I wish - hope with my whole heart - that there will be more. Otherwise, I'll be returning again and again simply just to study these and to relive their many, many profound, emotional, delightful twists and turns.

So… Kelly, why 4 stars? I don’t know, really, I assign star ratings based on gut instinct and I never really regarded these books as flawless, or technically perfect - there’s a lot of context and run-on stuff… it’s sort of like, the date was okay but the sex was awesome. Don’t worry about it, just read these fucking books, I’m out.

*sniff* Until next time...

Demon on: Amazon | Bookshop.org | Goodreads