Review: Rolling in the Deep
/3 stars. How fun is this?! Reads just like the beginning of a classic monster movie. Perfect for summer and perfect as a palette cleanser in-between long fantasy books and heavy literary horror. I have yet to read Drowning Deep but it's on my shortlist and I look forward to appreciating it even more with this context.
Imagine Networks commissions a documentary on mermaids (real or myth), and sends a well-equipped, expensive expedition to the Mariana Trench to capture some footage and/or scientific evidence. There's a production crew, a ship crew, a group of scientists of various specialties, interns, and some actual mermaids - outfitted with tails and everything - to ensure the network draws in the viewers they need no matter what. You know the rest.
It's an excellent premise. I enjoyed the clear research and commitment to detail. It's very front-heavy, with a very long intro to the characters that somehow makes it seem draggy/like the action is very delayed AND like the climax/action/ending is rushed. It's true that for the first 50% you're just waiting, and for the final 50% you're like... wait what? Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye.
I always admire and respect Seanan McGuire's intent to represent. She does a nice job in certain stories, in others it's a little heavy handed. Here it's the latter. Granted, some folks truly need to be hit over the head with some of this stuff - sometimes I do too!!!! But the way she incorporates her lessons/messages - unsubtly - feels ungraceful, and even distracting sometimes.
It's just my opinion. This is a silly review for a somewhat silly story. It's fun - it really is. While I wouldn't call it scary, there are some delightfully creepy moments. Read it on a hot summer day at the beach. Read it on a boat! I dare you to read it and stare into the ocean without wondering what might be staring back.